Should we get rid of the 1-10 scale?

[J u s T C]

This is why gaming and movie critics are moving/moved away from 1-10 rating scales ages ago. They mean nothing. All that matters is was it good? why was it good? why wasn't it good? what nees to be improved?

a 1-10 scales doesn't shed any light on these critical factors. It offers nothing constructive. no food for thought. especially when more people are rating the same piece using a 1 TO 10 because the ratings end up all over the place.

I can't judge if I'm doing something right when so many people of varying levels of knowledge are using a broad 1 to 10 scale. But if they explain the why's and hows I have something to take back to the drawing board to help improve in the future as well as the insight to judge whether or not they know what they're talking about/took the time to read.

[J u s T C]

This is why gaming and movie critics are moving/moved away from 1-10 rating scales ages ago. They mean nothing. All that matters is was it good? why was it good? why wasn't it good? what nees to be improved?

a 1-10 scales doesn't shed any light on these critical factors. It offers nothing constructive. no food for thought. especially when more people are rating the same piece using a 1 TO 10 because the ratings end up all over the place.

I can't judge if I'm doing something right when so many people of varying levels of knowledge are using a broad 1 to 10 scale. But if they explain the why's and hows I have something to take back to the drawing board to help improve in the future as well as the insight to judge whether or not they know what they're talking about/took the time to read.