Transgendered Athletes

[NOBLE]

Do you think it is fair for transgender women to compete in women's sports?

Post by ???.

[NOBLE]

Do you think it is fair for transgender women to compete in women's sports?

Post by ???.

[Seul]

No, just naturally men are generally stronger / bigger. Just imagine womens wrestling, you gonna have poor Katie getting suplexed by Big Dave, who now goes by Davina.

[Seul]

No, just naturally men are generally stronger / bigger. Just imagine womens wrestling, you gonna have poor Katie getting suplexed by Big Dave, who now goes by Davina.

[Edgeworth]

Interesting topic, I go with No. Transgender just means someone that identifies as the other sex besides the one they were born into. A person born physically a man will on average be genetically taller, stronger, faster etc than someone born a female. Just because this male now identifies as a female does not mean they should be allowed to compete in physical events with others who were born female. Have a transgender tier or compete with your birth sex, IMO.

[Edgeworth]

Interesting topic, I go with No. Transgender just means someone that identifies as the other sex besides the one they were born into. A person born physically a man will on average be genetically taller, stronger, faster etc than someone born a female. Just because this male now identifies as a female does not mean they should be allowed to compete in physical events with others who were born female. Have a transgender tier or compete with your birth sex, IMO.

Hell no. That's not fair at all smh now watch this blow up into a national story... *Facepalm

Hell no. That's not fair at all smh now watch this blow up into a national story... *Facepalm

[NOBLE]

But if someone who was born a male has the right to identify as a female, why wouldn't they have the right to compete in female sports?

[NOBLE]

But if someone who was born a male has the right to identify as a female, why wouldn't they have the right to compete in female sports?

[Bape]

Originally Posted by NOBLE

But if someone who was born a male has the right to identify as a female, why wouldn't they have the right to compete in female sports?

Men are naturally stronger than most women. If a man trained for 5 years in a sport compared to a women who trained 5 years in a sport, nine times out of ten the man would be superior.

[Bape]

Originally Posted by NOBLE

But if someone who was born a male has the right to identify as a female, why wouldn't they have the right to compete in female sports?

Men are naturally stronger than most women. If a man trained for 5 years in a sport compared to a women who trained 5 years in a sport, nine times out of ten the man would be superior.

Are they transitioning physically as well. Like hormone therapy Iin full effect. Are their Ps made into Vs. If it's just a dude living as a woman, than no way. That's not fair. If they have gone through years of hormone therapy to actually transition into a woman than I could see that.

Are they transitioning physically as well. Like hormone therapy Iin full effect. Are their Ps made into Vs. If it's just a dude living as a woman, than no way. That's not fair. If they have gone through years of hormone therapy to actually transition into a woman than I could see that.

Originally Posted by NOBLE

But if someone who was born a male has the right to identify as a female, why wouldn't they have the right to compete in female sports?

If I identify as siamese, can I get a tag team partner for my boxing match?

I don't specifically mind transgender woman competing in male sports. Honestly, I don't mind any woman competing in male sports as long as they have proven themselves to be capable of competing in a fair and safe manner. That being said, there's an entire field we can go down if you want to talk about steroids, testosterone boosters and what not when you're talking about a woman transitioning to a man.

The alternative, men to women, no fucking way. Fallon Fox can fuck right off. Men have a bone density, along with many other aspects, that aren't entirely taken away by oestrogen and testosterone blockers.

The whole "identify" thing is ridiculous to me. Like my example at the top, it seems ridiculous, but can you actually explain to me the difference between:-

Person is born a woman, identifies as a man, therefore is classified as male.
Person is born non-siamese, identifies as siamese, therefore is classified as siamese.
Person is born ailment free, identifies as someone with down syndrome, is classified as someone with down syndrome.

Genuinely, I'm very interested in what the difference between those are, specifically in the realm of sports and classifications.

Originally Posted by NOBLE

But if someone who was born a male has the right to identify as a female, why wouldn't they have the right to compete in female sports?

If I identify as siamese, can I get a tag team partner for my boxing match?

I don't specifically mind transgender woman competing in male sports. Honestly, I don't mind any woman competing in male sports as long as they have proven themselves to be capable of competing in a fair and safe manner. That being said, there's an entire field we can go down if you want to talk about steroids, testosterone boosters and what not when you're talking about a woman transitioning to a man.

The alternative, men to women, no fucking way. Fallon Fox can fuck right off. Men have a bone density, along with many other aspects, that aren't entirely taken away by oestrogen and testosterone blockers.

The whole "identify" thing is ridiculous to me. Like my example at the top, it seems ridiculous, but can you actually explain to me the difference between:-

Person is born a woman, identifies as a man, therefore is classified as male.
Person is born non-siamese, identifies as siamese, therefore is classified as siamese.
Person is born ailment free, identifies as someone with down syndrome, is classified as someone with down syndrome.

Genuinely, I'm very interested in what the difference between those are, specifically in the realm of sports and classifications.

Yea this whole lgbt trans b.s. is a joke especially when they have drag queens going into schools an shit telling five years olds it's ok to be gay in a manipulative way, and also yea it's just fucked.. I had a argument about this stuff with a heap of snowflake individuals and absolutely destroyed them all, trans is a mental illness called gender dysphoria, they have a high af sucide rate too, not because they are bullied but cause it's a mental illness other groups who feel bullied like blacks have much lower sucide rates.. As for atheletes there was a dude said he identifies as a chick then got to go into the octagon a beat up woman I think his name was something Fox.. it's funny how the trans mess up the feminist movement tho in some ways even tho they are kinda on the same team pretty much, like feminist hate guys but cause of trans now they have to go into bathrooms shared with guys, probably thinking every guy in der is gonna rape her, you seen those bath rooms? All this being sensitive to people in exchange for destroying and confusing society is not a good idea. People can be how they want but don't expect others to cater to you just because u think your some how special, I even saw an argument where a woman told a guy it's an attack to call her a woman... such mental illness.

Yea this whole lgbt trans b.s. is a joke especially when they have drag queens going into schools an shit telling five years olds it's ok to be gay in a manipulative way, and also yea it's just fucked.. I had a argument about this stuff with a heap of snowflake individuals and absolutely destroyed them all, trans is a mental illness called gender dysphoria, they have a high af sucide rate too, not because they are bullied but cause it's a mental illness other groups who feel bullied like blacks have much lower sucide rates.. As for atheletes there was a dude said he identifies as a chick then got to go into the octagon a beat up woman I think his name was something Fox.. it's funny how the trans mess up the feminist movement tho in some ways even tho they are kinda on the same team pretty much, like feminist hate guys but cause of trans now they have to go into bathrooms shared with guys, probably thinking every guy in der is gonna rape her, you seen those bath rooms? All this being sensitive to people in exchange for destroying and confusing society is not a good idea. People can be how they want but don't expect others to cater to you just because u think your some how special, I even saw an argument where a woman told a guy it's an attack to call her a woman... such mental illness.

^Disagree with all that bollocks, but shit like this Jim Parsons film where a 4 year old is transgendered is ridiculous. Kids aren't coming out of the womb like "Lemmy get at that pussy". A 4 year old doesn't have a sexual preference, nor does a 4 year old have gender preferences other than those handed to them. It's cool if we're talking 10 year olds, but if you handed me barbies instead of action men when I was 4 I'd have played with them instead.

^Disagree with all that bollocks, but shit like this Jim Parsons film where a 4 year old is transgendered is ridiculous. Kids aren't coming out of the womb like "Lemmy get at that pussy". A 4 year old doesn't have a sexual preference, nor does a 4 year old have gender preferences other than those handed to them. It's cool if we're talking 10 year olds, but if you handed me barbies instead of action men when I was 4 I'd have played with them instead.