Realistic Rating & Feedback ?

[Just C]

I rated this track a 3.... ..... Why? ..... 1) The beat selection was horrible, Especially for the persons "style", I'm using that word VERY LOOSELY ..... 2) He suffered from a seious lack of timing ..... 3) The hook was just plain weird ..... 4) He had abolutely no swag or charisma AT ALL ..... 5) Where is the content? I mean what I'm about to say is pretty relivant to the way I rated. This guy has been on this site for what? 4, 5 years? has over a THOUSAND BATTLES . has probablt posted a good say. 75 to say 150 tracks (collabs n features included) and yet he is STILL rapping the same way about the same shit. Isn't the whole point in us rapping to...Get better? ... And if not there has to come a point where you need to stop sugar coating how you feel about that persons music and tell him straigh up. "Im sorry but you suck, you've had your time. If you've not improved by now then I'm sorry but the odds are YOU NEVER WILL" so it's time for everyone to take of their rose tinted glasses and come back to reallity.. But yet people are on that track giving it 10s and lying to the kid. I had to insert a dose of reallity. Am I wrong for that? I don't know why I'm asking this. I guess I'm just bored and extremely curious to know what you guys think about this paticular case and track ratings as a whole. So check the track and let me know. If the link doesn't work it's the @ILLEST Marx track in the new tracks section. I'm not expecting you to bitch and be mean to the guy. But I also don't want you to avoid rthis thread like the plauge for fear of getting involved into some bullshit. I just wan't some honesty. straight down the middle honesty.

---------- Post added at 05:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:42 PM ----------

Bum biggidy bump!

---------- Post added at 05:28 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:10 PM ----------

Bum biggidy bumpa!

[Just C]

I rated this track a 3.... ..... Why? ..... 1) The beat selection was horrible, Especially for the persons "style", I'm using that word VERY LOOSELY ..... 2) He suffered from a seious lack of timing ..... 3) The hook was just plain weird ..... 4) He had abolutely no swag or charisma AT ALL ..... 5) Where is the content? I mean what I'm about to say is pretty relivant to the way I rated. This guy has been on this site for what? 4, 5 years? has over a THOUSAND BATTLES . has probablt posted a good say. 75 to say 150 tracks (collabs n features included) and yet he is STILL rapping the same way about the same shit. Isn't the whole point in us rapping to...Get better? ... And if not there has to come a point where you need to stop sugar coating how you feel about that persons music and tell him straigh up. "Im sorry but you suck, you've had your time. If you've not improved by now then I'm sorry but the odds are YOU NEVER WILL" so it's time for everyone to take of their rose tinted glasses and come back to reallity.. But yet people are on that track giving it 10s and lying to the kid. I had to insert a dose of reallity. Am I wrong for that? I don't know why I'm asking this. I guess I'm just bored and extremely curious to know what you guys think about this paticular case and track ratings as a whole. So check the track and let me know. If the link doesn't work it's the @ILLEST Marx track in the new tracks section. I'm not expecting you to bitch and be mean to the guy. But I also don't want you to avoid rthis thread like the plauge for fear of getting involved into some bullshit. I just wan't some honesty. straight down the middle honesty.

---------- Post added at 05:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:42 PM ----------

Bum biggidy bump!

---------- Post added at 05:28 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:10 PM ----------

Bum biggidy bumpa!