Surprised here. One dude had a decent concept/idea, but executed it poorly due to bad wording. The scheme just didn't sound or read natural at all. The other was more simplistic in his approach and execution, but his punch lacked in sting although it made much more sense. Good ratings for both, but leaned the way with the better overall punch.

I thought both went for similar style bars where they were weaving in little references and links up to the main punch. I think Mac's was layered a bit cleaner and his punch had more umph to it, even if a little obvious based on all the links. Think fidels felt a bit too statement-ish. Mac's had a bit more personal touch to it too which helps in a one bar if the other guy goes generic. Good bars, edge to Mac. 

i had to google mac's concept a little and ater doing all of that i think Fidel was just ahead for being much more direct and personal herewith the better conceptualization.

so both brought some good bar work by keeping everything relevant in the bar being that it's one bar I think it's important. Honestly one edged here because of the better delivery of the bar like multi placements and it makes it hit harder. Fairs in 

Fidel definitely didn't come at his best here, I've seen him in electric form of late but this really lacked the creativity and cleverness he usually has conceptually. Mac had a very topical and unique concept paired with pretty slick execution, whereas I guess Fiddy just felt a little bland here, with the kind of bar that has nothing wrong with it but just doesn't have anything memorable.

KILLERS

I get what fidel did at the end but seems a little goofy to me. I'm giving it to mac for that Nba/corona bar. Hilarious!

I liked Fidel's wp. It was fresh and a bit silly. Felt he could have definitely crafted it into a stronger punch. Mac had a decent bar. It just wasnt as clever or out of the box and that helped me decide on a winner. Give it to fidel.

Fidel I'm not gonna lie if you ended your punch with anything better I would have felt the whole thing. Felt solid setup wise but the ending felt missing. MAC your punch was simple yet relevant and effective enough to take the dub in my eyes. Good battle

KILLERS

One stood out more to me, other wasn't bad but lacked the impact to take the win imo.

Fidel..the concept was dope...the multies was forced tho'..which kinda hurt your punch but it still was good  

Mac ..concept was fresh and relevant..punch could've hit harder if set up different but it was creative 

close one..fairs in

Surprisingly, I had MacArthur taking this with a punch that hit a bit more for me. I didn't like how Fidel's mountain punch was flipped. The phrase "a mountain to nothing" doesn't really mean anything and there was no real payoff to it despite the uphill battle and head for heights setup. Close but I have my winner. Fair's in.

felt like one had better structure the other was trying to be creative but to not necessarily so. its a hit or a miss situation i feel. fair vote guys.