I just thought. it's finally become clear

[J u s T C]

Originally Posted by Phroxen

In general, this site is overly trigger happy with Hall of Fame nominations and inductees.

This. I agree. And that goes right across the board. Not with inductees. (though I disagree with a few RULEs doing a good job) but with nominations. But Tracks is always going to suffer from this more because the ability to achieve and bolster your CV makes it a lot more likely people will be nominated on their merits.

Where as tracks is all down to personal preference and shady favouritism because there aren't any achievements to separate the wheat from the chaff.

And lol Swag. I take full responsibility for that abomination.

[J u s T C]

Originally Posted by Phroxen

In general, this site is overly trigger happy with Hall of Fame nominations and inductees.

This. I agree. And that goes right across the board. Not with inductees. (though I disagree with a few RULEs doing a good job) but with nominations. But Tracks is always going to suffer from this more because the ability to achieve and bolster your CV makes it a lot more likely people will be nominated on their merits.

Where as tracks is all down to personal preference and shady favouritism because there aren't any achievements to separate the wheat from the chaff.

And lol Swag. I take full responsibility for that abomination.

[Revan]

Originally Posted by Murderous Swag

I say we all kill corb for creating a monster tbh

---------- Post added at 01:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:46 PM ----------

My tracks>felons tracks so wheres my hof title?

lol he had a good point tho, he and others might disagree with hindsight but the intial idea wasnt a bad one.

[Revan]

Originally Posted by Murderous Swag

I say we all kill corb for creating a monster tbh

---------- Post added at 01:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:46 PM ----------

My tracks>felons tracks so wheres my hof title?

lol he had a good point tho, he and others might disagree with hindsight but the intial idea wasnt a bad one.

[FreezyCT]

i definitely think there should be a HOF, but we need a better system - like whats been said...music in general comes down to personal preference, but in a way - so do text verses...but somehow weve managed to make a distinct difference between those two aspects

why cant it come down to specifics, like with text verses...you have punches, structure, setups, multis, a bunch of different ways to decide whos better...i say incorporate the same system...quality, flow, sticking to the theme of the song - things we can pick out, and use to compare/contrast...it doesnt take a genius to know if someones on beat or not

the first thing that needs to go is the rating system...fuck you and your 10s

[FreezyCT]

i definitely think there should be a HOF, but we need a better system - like whats been said...music in general comes down to personal preference, but in a way - so do text verses...but somehow weve managed to make a distinct difference between those two aspects

why cant it come down to specifics, like with text verses...you have punches, structure, setups, multis, a bunch of different ways to decide whos better...i say incorporate the same system...quality, flow, sticking to the theme of the song - things we can pick out, and use to compare/contrast...it doesnt take a genius to know if someones on beat or not

the first thing that needs to go is the rating system...fuck you and your 10s

On tracks, people need to be waaaay more analytical. All things should be considered. Sound quality, mixing, overall production, lyrical content, imagery, emotion, energy, flow, meaning, how well the emcee go their message across, so on and so forth. Once someone has mastered all these aspects, they shouldn't even be considered HOF worthy. Tbh HOF in general should be held at the HIGHEST merit, and not just something that's thrown around.
Phroxen hit it with the simplest explanation tbh.

On tracks, people need to be waaaay more analytical. All things should be considered. Sound quality, mixing, overall production, lyrical content, imagery, emotion, energy, flow, meaning, how well the emcee go their message across, so on and so forth. Once someone has mastered all these aspects, they shouldn't even be considered HOF worthy. Tbh HOF in general should be held at the HIGHEST merit, and not just something that's thrown around.
Phroxen hit it with the simplest explanation tbh.

^^ Agree but is it being considered stripping Felon of his HOF? You can't do that just tighten the guidelines ..

^^ Agree but is it being considered stripping Felon of his HOF? You can't do that just tighten the guidelines ..

[Revan]

Stripping anyone of a HOF title would be a last resort kinda thing.

Im hoping the need will not arise, unless cheating is revealed etc etc.

[Revan]

Stripping anyone of a HOF title would be a last resort kinda thing.

Im hoping the need will not arise, unless cheating is revealed etc etc.

[FreezyCT]

he cheated me out of seconds of my life that ill never get back..

[FreezyCT]

he cheated me out of seconds of my life that ill never get back..

[Phil Banks]

tbh site been real dead lately i think this the least of our problems

[Phil Banks]

tbh site been real dead lately i think this the least of our problems

[Fredo Lombardi]

Only if the track was actually hot but I'm guilty of giving 7 ratings to songs that deserve 4's but i'm just a nice guy.

[Fredo Lombardi]

Only if the track was actually hot but I'm guilty of giving 7 ratings to songs that deserve 4's but i'm just a nice guy.

[J u s T C]

Originally Posted by Phil Banks

tbh site been real dead lately i think this the least of our problems

Then do something.

[J u s T C]

Originally Posted by Phil Banks

tbh site been real dead lately i think this the least of our problems

Then do something.