[NOBLE]

ROUND 1
@GOOD GRIEF vs @Mind Fuck
(http://www.letsbeef.com/battle_detai...162&section=tb)
Mind Fuck: Anarchist: 7 / CulpritT: 8
GOOD GRIEF: Anarchist: 6 / CulpritT: 7
I felt GOOD GRIEF dropped the better overall vote in this match-up. His vote was more involved. He highlighted problem areas but also mentioned what they did well. Mind Fuck gave a nice synopsis as well, but GOOD GRIEF went into more detail and also gave a more personal perspective which can be beneficial to battlers. I also preferred GOOD GRIEF's ratings in this battle. If I had to vote, I probably would have given the same ratings. 8 and 7 just seems a bit high for the output of CulpritT and Anarchist in that battle to me.
Vote: GOOD GRIEF

---------- Post added at 04:08 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:07 AM ----------

@Unyqe vs @Ghambit
(http://www.letsbeef.com/battle_detai...n=tb&id=452307)
Ghambit: Adubs KiloG: 8 / opFOR: 8
Unyqe: Adubs KiloG: 6 / opFOR: 6
Honestly, I felt you both picked the wrong winner here and I voted in that battle as well. We must have been looking at two different things. I'm not going to compare my vote to yours though, I'm going to compare both your votes to each other, but suffice it to say that I generally disagreed with both your assessments of this battle. I felt Ghambit did better at explaining why he voted the way he did, but Unyqe gave a more realistic rating. 8's for those verses was kinda high. Both your votes have their merits, but due to a more thorough explanation, I'm giving my vote to Ghambit in this match-up.
Vote: Ghambit

---------- Post added at 04:51 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:08 AM ----------

@The Black Book vs @Phroxen
(http://www.letsbeef.com/battle_detai...166&section=tb)
The Black Book: Jimmy Dean™: 7 / Xplissit: 7
(http://www.letsbeef.com/battle_detai...n=tb&id=452516)
Phroxen: Adubs KiloG: 6 / Seiji: 5
Two different battles were randomly picked and examined here because you guys didn't vote on the same two battles. I felt you both gave accurate ratings for your respective battles, but The Black Book gave a more thorough explanation of his vote. I felt you both could have been less vague. Using terms like "one was smoother" or "one had some okay schemes", it's conceivable that the people you were addressing could have been unsure of exactly who you were referring to at certain points. I think this is something we've all been guilty of, but it is more preferable to be direct and say exactly who you're addressing in your expo. In this match-up, I'll have to say The Black Book dropped the better overall vote.
Vote: The Black Book

---------- Post added at 05:10 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:51 AM ----------

All of ILLoKWENT's judge points have been added for all 3 rounds. You guys can private message him if you need an expo on why he voted the way he did. I'll be back to drop my rates and expos for rounds 2 and 3 and still waiting on AfterThought.

[NOBLE]

ROUND 1
@GOOD GRIEF vs @Mind Fuck
(http://www.letsbeef.com/battle_detai...162&section=tb)
Mind Fuck: Anarchist: 7 / CulpritT: 8
GOOD GRIEF: Anarchist: 6 / CulpritT: 7
I felt GOOD GRIEF dropped the better overall vote in this match-up. His vote was more involved. He highlighted problem areas but also mentioned what they did well. Mind Fuck gave a nice synopsis as well, but GOOD GRIEF went into more detail and also gave a more personal perspective which can be beneficial to battlers. I also preferred GOOD GRIEF's ratings in this battle. If I had to vote, I probably would have given the same ratings. 8 and 7 just seems a bit high for the output of CulpritT and Anarchist in that battle to me.
Vote: GOOD GRIEF

---------- Post added at 04:08 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:07 AM ----------

@Unyqe vs @Ghambit
(http://www.letsbeef.com/battle_detai...n=tb&id=452307)
Ghambit: Adubs KiloG: 8 / opFOR: 8
Unyqe: Adubs KiloG: 6 / opFOR: 6
Honestly, I felt you both picked the wrong winner here and I voted in that battle as well. We must have been looking at two different things. I'm not going to compare my vote to yours though, I'm going to compare both your votes to each other, but suffice it to say that I generally disagreed with both your assessments of this battle. I felt Ghambit did better at explaining why he voted the way he did, but Unyqe gave a more realistic rating. 8's for those verses was kinda high. Both your votes have their merits, but due to a more thorough explanation, I'm giving my vote to Ghambit in this match-up.
Vote: Ghambit

---------- Post added at 04:51 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:08 AM ----------

@The Black Book vs @Phroxen
(http://www.letsbeef.com/battle_detai...166&section=tb)
The Black Book: Jimmy Dean™: 7 / Xplissit: 7
(http://www.letsbeef.com/battle_detai...n=tb&id=452516)
Phroxen: Adubs KiloG: 6 / Seiji: 5
Two different battles were randomly picked and examined here because you guys didn't vote on the same two battles. I felt you both gave accurate ratings for your respective battles, but The Black Book gave a more thorough explanation of his vote. I felt you both could have been less vague. Using terms like "one was smoother" or "one had some okay schemes", it's conceivable that the people you were addressing could have been unsure of exactly who you were referring to at certain points. I think this is something we've all been guilty of, but it is more preferable to be direct and say exactly who you're addressing in your expo. In this match-up, I'll have to say The Black Book dropped the better overall vote.
Vote: The Black Book

---------- Post added at 05:10 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:51 AM ----------

All of ILLoKWENT's judge points have been added for all 3 rounds. You guys can private message him if you need an expo on why he voted the way he did. I'll be back to drop my rates and expos for rounds 2 and 3 and still waiting on AfterThought.