I don't know in what context you took from your conversation that "a battle can't be re-opened," but battles can and do get reopened periodically. Even Jason told you in that other thread that if you have any questionable battles, feel free to show them to him and he will evaluate and determine if its worth reopening.
What you're asking to put into place already is in place. If anyone thinks they've been robbed or thinks their battle should be reopened, you may forward that battle to a mod and they will use their own discretion and either reopen it or not. If you're looking for more realistic votes, you can always drop your link in the FVC.
|