Like both, @
Punk & @
Erupt previously stated.
Have a basic minimum character limit and also create a system/voting structure based on certain categories. The current ones we have, even if they're on a battle, the chances are that no one uses them. If we have it so that you must select from 1-5 on each categorie (Meta's, Mulits, Personals, etc).. before the vote can be cast could be a good touch.
Maybe also have that show up in each individual vote too, so each battler can see what they were rated on each particular skill set by a voter under the main vote.
Example:
Erupt: Punk had the more coherent bars here. I feel... etc etc
X: 7 vs Punk: 8
X: Metas 3, Punk: Metas 4,
Multis 4, Multis 4,
Punches 4, Punches 5,
^Not perfect but you get the idea.