Still feel like comments being hidden till after a person votes will encourage more detailed votes ... Voters are worried about unintentionally swaying ... Or being acused of swaying on purpose ... Especially in tournaments where people try hard to be unbiased to the point nothing gets mentioned at all

Yes, Yes there titles need removal. LMFAO @ Xander...:high:

---------- Post added at 08:58 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:52 AM ----------

^^Yeah, i agree with that. Worth looking into, even over a period of time/trail basis. (if you're not feeling it).

My plan was to have the least performing members replaced periodically, like maybe every 6 weeks I will check their voting threads and find out who is least responding to theirs. Then we will hold another contest for people who still want to get in to replace them. I don't like the idea of people getting in the FVC and not actually voting, and FVC members will be made aware that they may lose their spot in this way.

Sounds good

@NOBLE lets not be So concerned on the rotation of duties & more on getting the right cadidates for the positions. Its one thing FVC members being active but the main thing needed is actual correct, educated, non-biased fair votes. As the members of the FVC in the past had only to make a thread wiith 5 links of "Good Voting" to get in, and most of that was them trying to look like they knew what they were on about, but hadn't a clue lol....

tbh just dont wanna see dumb wack fuckers in the FVC... lol

i dont think fiji osa should be in the new FVC just yet his vp has to be 0 for a reason

I agree. I never liked the whole "5 links of 'Good Voting' to get in" concept because someone can be a shitty voter and simply drop 5 well-explained votes just to get in. I think the process should be competitive, that's why I'm holding V.A.T. style tourneys to select who will be members. I'm confident that with the mod panel of judges over-seeing the competition, the best voters will come out on top. So far, I've had @Teek offer to oversee the text competition. I would ideally like 3 text mods for the text comp and 3 audio mods for the audio comp, so if any of you would like to be part of the selection process, feel free to step up.

---------- Post added at 12:53 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:48 PM ----------

I have reservations about his voting ability too tbh. But I allowed him to sign up because his vp is currently not at zero and he had been a member of both the text and audio FVC in the past. Him signing up does not guarantee automatic membership. He'd still have to prove himself to be a better voter than other people in the competition. You are welcomed to be on the mod panel of judges overseeing the audio FVC selection if you like @Phil Banks.

@NOBLE well if it's not to much trouble i'd like to be on the panel

Fiji someone who tends to let his feelings get in the way on top of that he tends to vote weird I just have reservations bout him getting lots of VP...... specially he was the first one to want off when Just C killed it

I hear you bro. You're on the panel so I just need 2 more audio mods. Once the competitions are up, I'll let you know what's up so you can judge them. I would advise judging based on how they vote in the actual competition though as opposed to how they may have voted in the past. But at the end of the day, it will be yours and the other audio mod's call as far as who will become a member in the FVC.
I mentioned to @RULE and also to Just C before he was demodded (and both agreed) the idea of having people that qualify for only the audio FVC or only the text FVC having their vp's set at 3 rather than 4. If they qualify for both, they can then have it set at 4. The reason is that some people are good text voters but are not good audio voters and vice versa. If their vp is set at 3, its still elevated but it reduces the adverse effects their votes may cause if they go and vote on a battle format (audio or text) they're not that familiar with.

i'm down for Judging either Text or Audio fam & yeah this V.A.T. tourney ish is a good way to get the best voters in.