Edge's Boxing Style Scorecard

[Shodan]

Originally Posted by Rieper

The question is: Would you rather have more consistent decent votes or great quality votes that are hardly ever seen?

Yes

[Shodan]

Originally Posted by Rieper

The question is: Would you rather have more consistent decent votes or great quality votes that are hardly ever seen?

Yes

[Edgeworth]

Originally Posted by Shodan

I might try this, if only to make voting require less effort and therefore give me slightly more motivation to do it.

To be clear, I think strict voting systems like this never result in really good votes because judging a battle is an intuitive process that can't be represented with a rubric of any of kind. A scorecard can result in decent votes though.

Yeah I can agree with that, and I’m just trying it out. I’m still going to vote on tourney battles how I normally do, for example, to keep those super high quality votes. I was hoping that the scorecard would both help uncertain/inconsistent voters make more sense of how to judge a battle. Also, it helps the battlers understand why you think they lost when they can see which of their lines got into which categories. Just something to mess around with for now.

[Edgeworth]

Originally Posted by Shodan

I might try this, if only to make voting require less effort and therefore give me slightly more motivation to do it.

To be clear, I think strict voting systems like this never result in really good votes because judging a battle is an intuitive process that can't be represented with a rubric of any of kind. A scorecard can result in decent votes though.

Yeah I can agree with that, and I’m just trying it out. I’m still going to vote on tourney battles how I normally do, for example, to keep those super high quality votes. I was hoping that the scorecard would both help uncertain/inconsistent voters make more sense of how to judge a battle. Also, it helps the battlers understand why you think they lost when they can see which of their lines got into which categories. Just something to mess around with for now.