Rhyming Scheme/Flow- Erupt
Vocabulary- Both came w/ vocab i think one probably had more but i'll give it a TIE
Topic/Meaning- both did good here imo but i liked the way Erupt approached it
Storytelling/Progression- Erupt did his thing.. both were good though
Emotion- umm imo Cath
Imagery- close imma give it to Cath.. i got a slightly better picture from his
Poetic Techniques- Erupt
Ending- again Erupt here. So my vote goes to Erupt.. good reads from both.