All 3 @
kikipeepee who had the most impact / most awards / best bars etc. For example @
Mayneak was inducted and he's got no permanent titles.
Personally I don't see a need for a point system because I think the system in place is fine:
Someone gets nominated, people have a public discussion, the staff has a private one and if there's enough support then they're inducted. I agree with Kiwi's point about some people may have titles but we also have to consider the amount of tournaments going on at the time, we used to only have 4-6 tournaments a year, 2 were Grand Championships, so it was prestigious to have any title.